Mystery Lover on Your List? Here Are 25 Perfect Gift Ideas for Them
Do you have a mystery lover on your shopping list? Whether they’re captivated by the intrigue of crime novels or can’t get enough of whodunit TV shows, finding the perfect gift that speaks to their passion for solving mysteries can be a thrilling task. From premium collectibles to budget-friendly buys, we’ve curated a list of thoughtful, creative gifts that will leave them sleuthing with joy. Whether it’s Sherlock Holmes or Agatha Christie who lights up their world, these options are sure to delight and keep them guessing.
Premium Presents ($50+):
- Sherlock Holmes Hardback Collector’s Books: For a devoted fan of the world’s most famous detective, this beautifully bound collection is a must-have. It’s more than a set of books—it’s a treasure that can take center stage on their bookshelf. Check it out here.
- Miss Marple Collector Paperback Collection: If she’s a fan of Agatha Christie’s sharp-eyed sleuth, this collector’s set brings together the wit and charm of Miss Marple in one elegant package. Perfect for cozy evenings with tea and a mystery. Check it out here.
Value-Packed Ideas ($26 – $50):
- Hunt a Killer Mystery Box: Mystery games in a box that challenge you to solve puzzles and reveal the criminal. Whether she tackles it solo or with friends, it’s the perfect way to test her detective skills! Check it out here.
- Only Murders in the Building Tote Bag: Let her show off her love for the quirky, popular mystery series with this fun and practical tote bag. Ideal for carrying books, groceries, or clues for her next case. Check it out here.
- Mystery is a Genre T-shirt: Comfortable and witty, this shirt celebrates mystery lovers everywhere. Perfect for cozy nights in with her favorite thriller or detective novel. Check it out here.
- Edgar Allan Poe “The Raven” Tote Bag: For fans of Poe’s haunting tales, this tote bag pays homage to one of his most iconic works. It’s stylish, literary, and a great way to carry essentials. Check it out here.
- Sherlock Holmes T-shirt: Classic and timeless, just like Sherlock himself. This shirt is a subtle way for her to show off her love for the world’s greatest detective. Check it out here.
- Edgar Allan Poe Journal: Whether she’s jotting down clues or simply keeping a diary, this Poe-inspired journal adds a touch of gothic mystery to her everyday writing. Check it out here.
Bargain Buys ($25 and less):
- Murder, She Wrote Mug: The original queen of cozy mysteries, Jessica Fletcher, returns with this nostalgic mug. Perfect for fans who remember sneaking in late-night episodes or those just discovering the brilliance of “Murder, She Wrote.” Check it out here.
- Nancy Drew Wine Bags: Combine a love for mysteries with the perfect wine accessory. These fun and quirky wine bags make a great addition to a night of solving puzzles with a glass of wine in hand. Check it out here.
- It’s a Good Day to Read a Mystery Tote: Every day is a good day to dive into a new mystery, and this tote is perfect for carrying her next thrilling read. Check it out here.
- Death on the Nile Poster/Card: A beautiful tribute to one of Agatha Christie’s most famous mysteries. Perfect for decorating her reading nook or adding to her collection of mystery memorabilia. Check it out here.
- Columbo Keychain: For fans of the clever yet unassuming detective, this keychain is a fun nod to the beloved TV character. It’s sure to spark conversation and bring a smile. Check it out here.
- Keep Calm and Watch British Murder Mysteries Tote: A fun and cheeky tote for anyone who loves the wit and intrigue of British crime shows. Whether it’s “Sherlock,” “Broadchurch,” or “Miss Marple,” this tote captures it all. Check it out here.
- St. Mary Mead Poster: Bring the charm of Miss Marple’s sleepy yet mystery-filled village to her home with this elegant poster. A great decorative piece for any Christie fan. Check it out here.
- Nancy Drew Journal: A nod to everyone’s favorite girl detective, this journal is perfect for note-taking, journaling, or maybe even solving a mystery or two. Check it out here.
- Murder on the Orient Express Book Necklace: The Murder on the Orient Express mini book necklace is a charming and literary accessory, perfect for any Agatha Christie fan who wants to carry a piece of their favorite mystery wherever they go. Check it out here.
- Murder Mystery Jigsaw Puzzle: What could be more perfect than combining the joy of a puzzle with the intrigue of a mystery? Solve the 500 pieces to reveal hidden clues and crack the case. Check it out here.
- Sherlock (TV show) Mug: For fans of the modern Sherlock adaptation, this mug is the ideal way to enjoy a cuppa while binge-watching their favorite episodes. Check it out here.
- The Cozy Cookbook: More than 100 Recipes from Today’s Bestselling Mystery Authors: Combining food and mystery, this cookbook is perfect for those who love culinary cozies and want to try their hand at recipes inspired by their favorite mystery novels. Check it out here.
- Christmas Sweater Party Murder Mystery Game Kit: A fun and interactive murder mystery game that’s perfect for holiday parties or office gift exchanges. It’s a white elephant gift that keeps on giving. Check it out here.
- Only Murders in the Building Weekly Planner: Help her keep track of her own “cases” with this weekly planner inspired by the hit series. A practical and stylish gift for any mystery lover. Check it out here.
- Clue the Movie, Poster/Card: A retro and playful gift for fans of the cult-classic film. It’s perfect for decorating her space with a little dash of humor and mystery. Check it out here.
- Crow/Murder Mug: A clever play on words, this mug is a witty gift for those who appreciate both puns and a good mystery. Check it out here.
- Bookstore Gift Card: When in doubt, a bookstore gift card is always a win. Whether it’s for a local indie shop or Bookshop.org, it allows her to pick out her next thrilling read with ease. Check it out here.
Shopping for a mystery lover doesn’t have to be a mystery in itself! From high-end collector’s editions to quirky budget-friendly finds, there’s something for every fan of the genre on this list. These gifts not only celebrate their love for all things mysterious, but they also add a touch of fun, style, and intrigue to their everyday life. So whether you’re giving a puzzle, a piece of memorabilia, or a thrilling book, you’re sure to leave your mystery-loving friend excited and grateful. Happy sleuthing!
